World Bank report: India’s GDP growth is negative if we factor in environmental loss

Copied from an excellent article “Factor in India’s environmental loss and all we have is negative growth” written by Jay Mazoomdaar for FirstPost on 4 August 2013. You can find links to the World Bank report and more, at the original FirstPost link above.

A July 2013 report from the World Bank explored road-maps to sustainable growth. The study’s admittedly conservative estimate of air and water pollution, scarcity of water, lack of sanitation, loss of soil, pastureland and forests puts the cost of damages at 5.7 percent of our GDP.

The report makes it clear that lack of data did not allow it to factor in loss of fisheries, biodiversity, non-use (ecological) value of forests etc which would have significantly added to the damage. For example, the non-use and bio-prospecting value of forests could be as much as 6-20 times the use values. Clearly, the total cost of environmental damage far outweighs the 6.6 percent growth in GDP.

The Bank study says that particulate pollution (PM10) from the burning of fossil fuels has serious health consequences, amounting to 3 percent of India’s GDP. Of this, the impact of outdoor air pollution accounts for the highest share, at 1.7 percent, followed by the cost of indoor air pollution at 1.3 percent. Sustained exposure of the young and productive urban population to particulate matter pollution results in substantial cardiopulmonary and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease mortality.

A significant portion of diseases caused by inadequate water supply, sanitation and hygiene affects by children under 5. About 23 percent of child mortality in India could be attributed to environmental degradation, the report says. Cropland and pastureland damages arise from the decline in the value of crops due to topsoil erosion, water logging, salinity and overgrazing, while unsustainable logging practices and over-exploitation of forest resources cause forest degradation. The report pegs the total cost of these environmental damages at $80 billion.

For more, read the original FirstPost article linked above!

A reader left an interesting comment at that original FirstPost article:

“Particulate pollution has serious health consequences, amounting to 3 percent of GDP”

—-So if SPMs are eliminated, hospitals and doctors and nurses and pharma companies will make less money, and GDP will drop by 3%. Can’t afford that in the current state of the economy. Moral of the story, portions of GDP need to associated with a PLUS or MINUS sign. As long as cleaning up oil spills, placing people on life support after a five-car crash, and supplying meals to Sanjay Dutt in jail are all POSITIVE GDP, same sign as funding a little orphan girl’s school fees and meals, NOTHING will change.


About Gu'an

Blog: iamamangoman DOT wordpress DOT com
Gallery | This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to World Bank report: India’s GDP growth is negative if we factor in environmental loss

  1. Hi, I loved reading your comments on various Internet sites.I think post 16th may, you have stopped.I am not sure if that is because because of the seemingly colossal loss suffered by AAP or you are genuinely busy or you are thinking of a different strategy.If the reason is the first one, then i will strongly urge you not to get disheartened.The journey and fight was any way long, we need another 5-10 years to effect the change.
    Sorry in case you didn’t like my comment, but if you wish you can reach me at

    • Gu'an says:

      Hi, thanks for those encouraging words. I have a ton of work that I had put on the back burner for quite sometime. I am taking a break now from active political commenting for now. Waiting for the dust to settle down.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s